Roofing

When You Should Consider Roof Replacement Over Repair

September 25, 2023 by TGAR Admin

Roof maintenance and repairs are essential for prolonging the lifespan of your home’s protective shield. However, there are instances when roof replacement becomes the wiser investment. Our leaking roof experts at The Great American Roofing Company share three situations where opting for a new roof is better than repairs:

1. Aging Roof

An aging roof becomes less efficient at safeguarding your home from the elements. Shingles may curl, crack, or become brittle over time, compromising their ability to keep out moisture and withstand wind. You may also have to deal with the many issues of a leaking roof if it is nearing the end of its expected lifespan, which is typically 20-25 years for asphalt shingles. Replacing it can provide long-term peace of mind and energy efficiency benefits.

2. Extensive Damage

When your roof has suffered extensive damage, especially after a severe storm, a roof replacement might be more cost-effective in the long run. While repairs can address specific issues of a damaged roof, they may not fully resolve underlying problems or prevent future issues. A new roof ensures comprehensive protection and minimizes the risk of recurring damage.

3. Energy Efficiency Concerns

An aging roof also has poor insulation and/or inadequate ventilation, which can lead to energy inefficiency in your home. Both issues can lead to a significant increase in energy bills. Upgrading to a new, energy-efficient roof can significantly reduce energy consumption and improve the overall comfort in your home. Consider materials like cool roofing or insulation options for maximum efficiency.

Before making a decision to have your roof replaced, consult with a professional roofing contractor to assess the condition of your roof and discuss your specific needs and budget. They can help you determine whether a roof replacement is the best course of action. Remember, a well-maintained roof is essential for the safety and integrity of your home, so choose the option that provides the most durable and lasting solution.

Get Professional Services

Knowing when to opt for a roof replacement over repairs can save you time, money, and unnecessary stress. And remember, you don’t have to navigate these decisions alone. If you’re in Upper Saddle River, NJ, and need expert roofing services, contact The Great American Roofing Company at (201) 825-2955. You can also visit our contact page to request a free quote. We’re here to ensure your roof stands up to the test of time!

4.9 Over 125 Reviews

Write a Review

Kathy Farley 2 months ago

Great roofing company to work with. Not only does the roof look great but they were on time day of scheduled roofing, kept me apprised of milestones, very easy to communicate with (from sales through completion) and top notch site cleanup.

...

Alice Bausewein 3 months ago

Very professional company. Great work, clean up after the job. Highly recommend for work done at your home.

tamara hammer 4 months ago

Great experience! Highly recommend!

William Daly 4 months ago

Everything went perfectly from speaking with Ryan the salesman who was very professional to Steven and his crew who got the job done in a timely and professional manner also. I would highly recommend great American roofing

Galina 4 months ago

Thank you GARC for an amazing work!
The great company, indeed!
Would recommend to everyone who are planning to replace the roof.

steve Karow 4 months ago

When having to replace the roof on your home it can be a very upsetting process due to the extensive cost involved. We are 100% sure we made the right choice going with GARC.
We had seen at least 3 other roofing companies and only Ryan was interested in going into my attic to see how the structure of the home was and make sure there were no issues from the inside out.
He then explained the issues we were having and what GARC would do to fix these with their new roof system.

When we met with the other roof companies we felt they would replace the roof but were not comfortable with them.

Pricing was definitely and issue and when we weighed all we did not go with the cheapest nor the most expensive. GARC was very competitive and with their warranty we felt that was most important for the future.

Stephen and his crew finished our job in one day when we were told at least 2. They worked from dawn to dusk to get our job done.

A week later and we had 3” of rain fall. The home was perfectly protected and no issues.

GARC is a family run business and not a large conglomerate. They are extremely accommodating and friendly to work with.

I cannot recommend them more if you are looking to replace your roof.

Thom Herron 5 months ago

I highly recommend Great American Roofing for any of your roofing needs. Very professional and clean. The estimate process went very smoothly and Ryan walked me patiently through all the details. Steven was a great on-site Forman, kept the team on track and did an excellent job at completing the job on time and on budget. Thanks GARC! A job well done.

Stephanie Smith 7 months ago

I can’t say enough good things about The Great American Roofing Company. We now have a beautiful new roof, and we couldn’t be happier.
Larry, the owner, Ryan, the operations manager, Andrea, the office manager, and Stephen, the head foreman were all great to work with. They were knowledgeable, professional, honest, friendly, and helpful. No pressure, and no requests or questions were left unanswered. What could have been a painful and stressful experience, turned out to be a smooth and easy process.Their expertise and friendliness added to the overall positive atmosphere. And to top it off, the roof replacement cleanup was perfect. Larry and his team went above and beyond to ensure a seamless and satisfying experience.
So all in all, excellent customer service and quality craftsmanship. We highly recommend GARC to everyone.

Cailyn Lynn 7 months ago

Summary:
Highly recommend, especially for a newer homeowner who is still learning like us. They are a company you can trust to do a great job for a fair price.

Details:
After meeting with 3 other companies in the area, we ultimately chose GARC based on its Master Elite GAF status. We have a friend in commercial roofing who told us how distinguished and important it is. They unquestionably live up to the hype.

Ryan was our salesperson - he came to the house at our convenience. He thoroughly explained the entire process, let us touch the materials and ask questions. We were given a very reasonable quote (based on calculations our friend did for us ahead of time) to replace our home and carport roof with the highest standard shingle as well as replace all of our gutters and downspouts including leaf guards.

Andrea helped schedule us for installation and was understanding and accommodating when we had to reschedule. There was a 2-week lead time. They took care of all the permits for the dumpster, etc. (which the town made very difficult for them - definitely went above and beyond on this front).

Steven was our project manager and he came with a large team at 7am on our scheduled day. They worked hard all day long, finishing the project about 4:30pm just as daylight began fading. They were respectful of our property and landscaping, cleaned up after themselves thoroughly, and were courteous.

Roof looks great and we are very happy.

When You Should Consider Roof Replacement Over Repair

Get Professional Services

WE ARE GAF MASTER ELITE

LIFETIME WARRANTY

SHINGLES

WE ARE GAF MASTER ELITE

The Great American Roofing Company